Should you choose Small Pet Select 2nd Cutting Timothy Hay for your rabbit or guinea pig? After evaluating this premium US-grown hay against numerous alternatives, this product delivers exceptional quality that justifies its higher price point for most small pet owners.
Small Pet Select sources their timothy hay exclusively from family farms in the Pacific Northwest, where the cool, dry climate produces hay with optimal fiber content and minimal dust. The 2nd cutting designation means this hay was harvested during the plant's second growth cycle, resulting in a softer texture with slightly higher protein content compared to 1st cutting varieties.
The 12-pound package arrives compressed but expands significantly once opened. The hay maintains excellent green color and fresh smell, indicating proper curing and storage. Unlike many competitors that arrive brown or musty, this hay consistently shows the vibrant appearance that indicates retained nutrients.
Ingredients & Nutrition
This is 100% pure timothy hay with no additives, preservatives, or artificial ingredients. The
AAFCO recognizes timothy hay as an essential fiber source for rabbits, guinea pigs, and chinchillas, providing the high-fiber, low-calcium content these animals require.
The 2nd cutting offers approximately 30-32% crude fiber and 8-10% crude protein - optimal levels for adult rabbits and guinea pigs. This protein content supports healthy weight maintenance without the excess calcium found in alfalfa hay that can cause urinary issues in adult small pets.
Each strand maintains good length (6-8 inches typically), encouraging natural foraging behaviors while providing the dental wear these animals need. The minimal dust content reduces respiratory irritation common with lower-grade hays.
Who It's Best For
Perfect for adult rabbits, guinea pigs, and chinchillas over 6 months old who need high-quality daily fiber. The 2nd cutting softness makes it particularly suitable for senior pets or those with sensitive teeth who struggle with coarser 1st cutting varieties.
Pet owners dealing with picky eaters often find success with this hay's appealing texture and smell. The consistent quality eliminates the frustration of variable batches common with store-bought options.
However, this isn't suitable for baby rabbits under 6 months, who require the higher calcium content of alfalfa hay. The premium price also makes it less practical for owners of multiple large rabbits who go through several pounds weekly.
Feeding Guidelines
Unlimited timothy hay should comprise 80-85% of your rabbit's diet, with guinea pigs requiring similar amounts. A typical adult rabbit (4-6 lbs) consumes roughly 2-3 ounces daily, meaning this 12-pound bag lasts approximately 8-10 weeks for a single rabbit.
Always ensure hay is available 24/7 in a clean feeder to support digestive health and prevent GI stasis. Store the remaining hay in a cool, dry location away from direct sunlight. The original packaging works adequately for short-term storage, but transferring to an airtight container extends freshness for the full bag.
Remove any hay that becomes wet or moldy immediately. While this premium hay resists mold better than cheaper alternatives, proper storage remains essential.
The Bottom Line
Small Pet Select Timothy Hay delivers exceptional value for pet owners prioritizing quality over price. The consistent freshness, minimal waste, and palatability make it worthwhile despite costing 40-50% more than pet store alternatives.
Where it falls short is the premium pricing that may strain budgets for owners of multiple pets or very large rabbits. The compressed packaging, while space-efficient for shipping, can be initially challenging to break apart.
Consult your veterinarian before making significant dietary changes, especially if your pet has a history of digestive issues or is transitioning from a different hay type.
