LuvemPets

Expert Pet Product Reviews

​
​
LuvemPets

Expert pet product reviews for dogs, cats, birds, fish, and more

Company
AboutPrivacy PolicyTerms of UseAffiliate Disclosure
Pet Products
All ReviewsNew ReleasesTop Rated
Explore
DogsCatsBirdsFishSmall Pets
Our Network
LuvemPets
LuvemBooks
LuvemHome

© 2026 LuvemPets. All rights reserved.

Built by capNotion

  1. Home
  2. Product Reviews
  3. Small Pets
  4. Small Pet Select 1st Cut Timothy Hay Pet

Small Pet Select 1st Cut Timothy Hay Pet Food for Rabbits, Guinea Pigs, and Other Small Animals, Easy to Store Box, 10 LB by Small
PETS

Small Pet Select Timothy Hay Review: Premium Quality

4.5

·

7 min read

$32.99 on Amazon
Reviewed by

LuvemPets

·

Mar 29, 2026

Small Pet Select 1st Cut Timothy Hay provides consistently high quality nutrition for rabbits and guinea pigs with excellent freshness and minimal waste. The premium price and large quantity may not suit all budgets or household sizes.

Our Review

In This Review
  • What We Love & Watch Out For
  • Ingredients & Nutrition
  • Who It's Best For
  • Feeding Guidelines
  • The Bottom Line

What We Love & Watch Out For

What We Love
  • Consistently fresh with vibrant green color and sweet aroma indicating proper harvest and storage
  • Minimal dust and stem waste compared to lower-grade timothy hays
  • Convenient 10-pound box packaging that maintains freshness better than plastic bags
  • Ideal fiber and protein content for adult rabbits and guinea pigs
  • Cost-effective for multi-pet households or heavy hay consumers
Watch Out For
  • Premium pricing significantly higher than basic pet store timothy hay
  • Large 10-pound quantity may be excessive for single-pet households
  • Cardboard packaging sometimes arrives damaged during shipping
  • May be too rich for some senior pets with sensitive digestive systems
Ready to buy?
$32.99 - Amazon
Looking for high-quality timothy hay that keeps rabbits and guinea pigs healthy? Small Pet Select 1st Cut Timothy Hay delivers consistently fresh, nutritious fiber that forms the foundation of a proper small animal diet.
Small Pet Select 1st Cut Timothy Hay Pet Food for _main_0
This 10-pound box provides excellent value for multi-pet households or regular hay consumers. The packaging keeps hay fresh longer than traditional baled hay, and the quality remains remarkably consistent batch after batch.
The hay arrives with vibrant green color and that fresh, sweet aroma that indicates proper harvesting and storage. Unlike lower-grade hays that often contain excessive dust or brown stems, this 1st cut timothy maintains its nutritional integrity with minimal waste.

Ingredients & Nutrition

Pure 1st cut timothy hay with no additives or preservatives - exactly what healthy rabbits and guinea pigs need. First cut timothy provides the ideal fiber profile with higher stem content than later cuts, promoting proper dental wear and digestive health.
The protein content runs approximately 8-10%, which is perfect for adult rabbits and guinea pigs. This protein level supports maintenance without causing the weight gain or urinary issues associated with richer hays like alfalfa.
Fiber content exceeds 32%, providing the indigestible fiber necessary for proper cecotrophy (the process where rabbits re-ingest certain droppings to maximize nutrient absorption). The AAFCO recognizes timothy hay as an essential component of small herbivore diets.
The calcium-to-phosphorus ratio remains appropriate for adult animals, though pregnant or nursing mothers may need calcium supplementation through pellets or occasional alfalfa hay.

Who It's Best For

Perfect for adult rabbits over 6 months old who need unlimited hay access. Guinea pigs of all ages thrive on this timothy hay as their primary food source, requiring about 1 cup per pound of body weight daily.
Multi-pet households benefit significantly from the 10-pound bulk packaging. The cost per serving drops considerably compared to smaller pet store bags, and the cardboard box storage system keeps hay fresher than plastic bags.
Ideal for picky eaters who reject lower-quality hays. The consistent green color and sweet smell entice even finicky rabbits and guinea pigs to maintain proper consumption levels.
Senior rabbits with dental issues find the varied stem textures helpful for natural tooth grinding, though extremely elderly animals might need softer 2nd or 3rd cut timothy hay mixed in.
This hay works well for chinchillas too, though they typically require smaller quantities than rabbits or guinea pigs.

Feeding Guidelines

Rabbits need unlimited timothy hay access - literally as much as they can eat. A 4-pound rabbit typically consumes 2-4 ounces of hay daily, but individual appetite varies significantly.
Guinea pigs require approximately 1 cup of hay per pound of body weight. A 2-pound guinea pig needs about 2 cups daily, adjusted based on body condition and activity level.
Supervision isn't required - timothy hay should be available 24/7. Replace hay that becomes soiled or loses its fresh smell, typically every 2-3 days depending on your pet's eating habits.
The box design allows easy portion control. Simply grab handfuls as needed rather than struggling with compressed bales. Store the opened box in a cool, dry location away from direct sunlight.
Monitor your pet's hay consumption patterns. Sudden decreases in hay eating often indicate dental problems or illness requiring veterinary attention.

The Bottom Line

Small Pet Select 1st Cut Timothy Hay delivers exceptional quality that justifies the premium price. The consistent freshness, minimal dust, and convenient packaging make daily feeding simpler while ensuring optimal nutrition.
The 10-pound size suits committed small pet owners who understand hay's importance in herbivore diets. Budget-conscious owners might find smaller quantities more economical initially, but the per-serving cost advantage becomes clear with regular use.
Where this hay falls short: the premium pricing puts it beyond some budgets, and the large quantity might overwhelm single-pet households with limited storage space.
The cardboard packaging occasionally arrives damaged during shipping, though this rarely affects the hay quality inside.
Consult your veterinarian before making significant dietary changes, especially for pets with existing health conditions or unusual eating patterns.

This post contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you purchase through these links at no additional cost to you.

Share This Review
Browse Categories

Small Pets

Popular Reviews
POPULAR
RECENT
TRENDY

Wild Harvest Universal Blend Review: Complete Nutrition?

3/29/2026

Bio-Groom Dog Shampoo Review: Eliminates Tough Odors

3/29/2026

AHJ Aquarium Heater Review: Reliable Tank Control

3/29/2026