LuvemPets

Expert Pet Product Reviews

​
​
LuvemPets

Expert pet product reviews for dogs, cats, birds, fish, and more

Company
AboutPrivacy PolicyTerms of UseAffiliate Disclosure
Pet Products
All ReviewsNew ReleasesTop Rated
Explore
DogsCatsBirdsFishSmall Pets
Our Network
LuvemPets
LuvemBooks
LuvemHome

© 2026 LuvemPets. All rights reserved.

  1. Home
  2. Product Reviews
  3. Small Pets
  4. Small Pet Select 2nd Cutting Perfect Blend Timothy

Small Pet Select 2nd Cutting Perfect Blend Timothy Hay Pet Food for Rabbits, Guinea Pigs, Chinchillas and Other Small Animals, Premium Natural Hay Grown in The US, 12 LB by Small
PETS

Small Pet Select Timothy Hay Review: Premium USA Quality

4

·

6 min read

$36.99 on Amazon
Reviewed by

LuvemPets

·

Mar 17, 2026

High-quality USA-grown timothy hay that provides excellent nutrition for rabbits, guinea pigs, and chinchillas. The premium price reflects superior sourcing and consistency, though budget-conscious owners have cheaper alternatives available.

Our Review

In This Review
  • What We Love & Watch Out For
  • Ingredients & Nutrition
  • Who It's Best For
  • Feeding Guidelines
  • The Bottom Line

What We Love & Watch Out For

What We Love
  • USA-grown timothy hay with traceable sourcing from Pacific Northwest farms
  • Fresh, sweet aroma and appealing green color indicate proper harvesting and storage
  • 12-pound size provides good value for multi-pet households or regular users
  • Single-ingredient formula without artificial additives or preservatives
  • Consistent second cutting texture suitable for multiple small pet species
Watch Out For
  • Higher price point compared to generic timothy hay brands
  • 12-pound quantity may be excessive for single-pet households with limited storage
  • Not appropriate for baby rabbits who need alfalfa hay's higher calcium content
  • Some pets may prefer softer third cutting timothy hay texture
Ready to buy?
$36.99 - Amazon
Should you choose Small Pet Select 2nd Cutting Perfect Blend Timothy Hay for your small pets? This premium hay blend has earned recognition among rabbit, guinea pig, and chinchilla owners for its consistent quality and USA-grown sourcing. The 12-pound bag provides substantial value for households with multiple small pets or those looking to stock up on this dietary staple.
Small Pet Select 2nd Cutting Perfect Blend Timothy_main_0
Small Pet Select sources their timothy hay exclusively from farms in the Pacific Northwest, where the climate produces the ideal texture and nutritional profile that small herbivores need. The second cutting variety offers the perfect balance between the coarser first cutting and the softer third cutting, making it suitable for daily feeding across different small pet species.
The packaging showcases vibrant imagery that immediately communicates the product's target audience, featuring an appealing rabbit design that catches the eye on store shelves or online listings. The 12-pound size strikes a practical balance—large enough to provide value but manageable enough for most pet owners to handle and store conveniently.

Ingredients & Nutrition

This timothy hay contains a single ingredient: 100% timothy grass (Phleum pratense) grown in the United States. The absence of artificial additives, preservatives, or fillers makes it a clean choice for pets with sensitive digestive systems.
Second cutting timothy hay typically contains 32-34% crude fiber, 8-10% protein, and maintains the essential balance of calcium to phosphorus that adult rabbits, guinea pigs, and chinchillas require. The fiber content supports proper dental wear—crucial for species whose teeth grow continuously throughout their lives.
The hay's natural green color and fresh aroma indicate proper harvesting and storage techniques. Quality timothy hay should smell sweet and grassy, without any musty odors that could indicate mold or improper curing. Small Pet Select's processing methods help preserve these characteristics through packaging and distribution.

Who It's Best For

Perfect for adult rabbits over six months old, this timothy hay serves as the foundation of a proper herbivore diet. Adult guinea pigs benefit from the balanced nutrition, while chinchillas can use it as their primary hay source alongside pellets and occasional treats.
Multi-pet households find particular value in this product since the same hay works across different small herbivore species. The 12-pound size accommodates the needs of several pets or provides a month's supply for a single large rabbit with healthy appetite.
Pet owners seeking consistent quality appreciate that Small Pet Select maintains strict sourcing standards. The USA-grown guarantee provides traceability that some imported hays cannot offer, giving peace of mind about growing conditions and handling practices.
This hay isn't suitable for baby rabbits under six months, who require the higher calcium content found in alfalfa hay. Extremely picky eaters might prefer the softer texture of third cutting timothy, though most pets adapt well to second cutting's moderate texture.

Feeding Guidelines

Provide unlimited access to timothy hay for rabbits and chinchillas—they should consume a pile roughly the size of their body each day. Guinea pigs require similar unlimited access, as hay should comprise 75-80% of their total diet.
Store the hay in a cool, dry location away from direct sunlight. The original bag works for short-term storage, but transferring to a breathable container like a wooden hay box helps maintain freshness for the full 12-pound quantity. Always check for any signs of mold or unusual odors before offering hay to your pets.
Rotate through your hay supply regularly, using older portions first to maintain peak nutritional value. Fresh hay should feel slightly springy and maintain its green color—brown, brittle hay has lost much of its nutritional benefit.

The Bottom Line

Small Pet Select 2nd Cutting Perfect Blend Timothy Hay delivers reliable quality that justifies its premium positioning in the small pet food market. The consistent texture, fresh aroma, and USA sourcing provide confidence for pet owners prioritizing their animals' daily nutrition needs.
While the price point exceeds some budget alternatives, the quality difference becomes apparent in the hay's appearance, smell, and your pets' enthusiasm for eating it. The 12-pound size offers practical value for committed small pet owners without overwhelming storage requirements.
The hay works excellently for its intended purpose, though extremely cost-conscious owners might find suitable alternatives at lower price points. Overall, this product represents solid value for pet parents willing to invest in premium nutrition for their herbivorous companions.
Consult your veterinarian before making significant changes to your pet's diet, especially if your animal has existing health conditions or dietary sensitivities.

This post contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you purchase through these links at no additional cost to you.

Share This Review
Browse Categories

Small Pets

Popular Reviews
POPULAR
RECENT
TRENDY

Oxbow Pure Comfort Review: Low-Dust Paper Bedding

3/17/2026

Small Pet Select 3rd Cutting Review: Ultra-Soft Hay

3/17/2026

Wild Harvest Ferret Food Review: High-Protein Choice

3/17/2026