Should you get Temptations MixUps Surfer's Delight for your cat? This 16-ounce tub combines three seafood flavors - tuna, shrimp, and salmon - in a mix of crunchy and soft textures that most cats find irresistible. The dual-texture format keeps treat time interesting, while the generous portion size offers good value for multi-cat households.
The standout feature here is the texture variety. Each treat has a crunchy shell with a soft center, mimicking the hunting satisfaction cats crave. The seafood blend appeals to cats who typically prefer fish-based foods over poultry options. The 16-ounce tub provides roughly 400 individual treats, making it cost-effective for regular training sessions or daily rewards.
However, these treats are calorie-dense at about 2 calories per piece. Cats who already struggle with weight should receive limited portions, and the rich seafood flavoring may be too intense for sensitive stomachs. Some cats experience digestive upset when transitioning from milder treats to these robust flavors.
Ingredients & Nutrition
The ingredient list leads with chicken by-product meal and ground corn, followed by animal fat preserved with mixed tocopherols. The seafood flavors come from natural tuna, salmon, and shrimp flavoring rather than whole fish proteins. While not premium ingredients, they meet
AAFCO standards for cat treat formulations.
Each treat contains approximately 2 calories with 35% crude protein and 17% crude fat. The protein content supports muscle maintenance, while the moderate fat level provides energy without excessive calories. The treats contain no artificial colors, though they do include natural flavoring and preservatives for shelf stability.
Cats with fish allergies should avoid this product entirely, as the multiple seafood flavors increase the risk of allergic reactions. The corn content may also trigger sensitivities in grain-sensitive cats.
Who It's Best For
Perfect for food-motivated cats who need training incentives, these treats work exceptionally well for teaching commands, encouraging carriers, or rewarding good behavior. The dual texture keeps picky eaters engaged, while the strong seafood aroma attracts even hesitant cats.
Multi-cat households benefit from the large tub size and variety pack format. Each cat can enjoy their preferred flavor without requiring separate purchases. The resealable tub maintains freshness for weeks, making it practical for occasional treat giving.
Senior cats often appreciate the softer centers, which are easier to chew than fully crunchy alternatives. The rich flavoring compensates for age-related taste decline that affects many older cats.
This product isn't suitable for kittens under 12 months, overweight cats on restricted diets, or cats with known seafood allergies. Cats with sensitive digestive systems may experience loose stools from the rich flavoring and higher fat content.
Feeding Guidelines
Temptations recommends no more than 15 treats per day for average adult cats, though this seems generous for most pets. A more practical approach limits portions to 5-10 treats daily, using them specifically for training or special rewards rather than casual snacking.
For cats over 12 pounds, reduce portions to prevent weight gain. Each treat represents roughly 1% of a 10-pound cat's daily caloric needs, so they add up quickly with regular feeding. Store the tub in a cool, dry location and use within 90 days of opening for optimal freshness.
Break treats into smaller pieces for training sessions to extend their effectiveness while controlling calories. The soft centers separate easily from the crunchy shells, allowing portion customization based on your cat's size and dietary needs.
The Bottom Line
Temptations MixUps Surfer's Delight delivers excellent value for seafood-loving cats who respond well to high-value training treats. The texture variety and strong flavoring make them effective motivators, while the large tub size suits households with multiple cats or frequent training needs.
The main drawbacks involve calorie density and digestive sensitivity potential. These treats work best as occasional rewards rather than daily supplements, particularly for indoor cats with lower activity levels.
For the price point, you're getting a treat that most cats genuinely enjoy and that maintains freshness throughout extended use. Just monitor portions carefully and watch for any digestive changes when first introducing them.
Consult your veterinarian before adding new treats to cats with existing health conditions or dietary restrictions.
